LE GRAND TESTAMENT - CXLII-CXLIII THE TESTAMENT - CXLII-CXLIII
François Villontr. Peter Dean
CXLII

Item, a maistre Andry Courault
Les Contreditz Franc Gontier mande;
Quant du tirant seant en hault,
A cestuy la riens ne demande:
Le Saige ne veult que contende
Contre puissant povre homme las,
Affin que ses filletz ne tende
Et qu'il ne trebuche en ses las.


CXLIII

Gautier ne crains: il n'a nulz hommes,
Et mieulx que moy n'est herité
Mais en ce debat cy nous sommes,
Car il louë sa povreté,
Estre povre yver et esté,
Et a felicité reppute
Ce que tiens a maleureté.
Lequel a tort? Or en discute.
CXLII

Item, I send the Refutation
of Frank Gontier to Andry Courault:
let not the tyrant in his station
be asked for anything by the low.
The sage neither wishes nor contends
that poor men fight against the strong,
thus they avoid the nets which wide he sends
and are not tramelled in his snares of thong.


CXLIII

Gontier’s no sweat: he had no men,
inherited no more than me,
but, in the debate that we’re now in,
since he has praised his poverty -
and calls that happy that should be
(just think! Poor, winter and summer long!)
ascribed only to misery:
let’s take that up and see who’s wrong.

Trans. Copyright © Peter Dean 2003


next
VB17 index
French index